I agree with the principle but not with method. That method has too often been used on other forums, and on this one too when we had a mod, (mugaliens) to repress valid criticisms. I suggested an integrty scoring system simply to expose posters and to warn readers of low integrity posters. All open and above board. Naturally, the ones who opposed are the ones who would score lowest, grapes, mugaliens.
Here are those suggestions
What can we do to improve this forum?
[what this board needs to do to improve]