You make it sound reasonable... yet, what you do with that information is vigorously attack the person every chance you get. You use others names and personal information like a weapon. Regardless of reality. You add your spin, your flavor, your distortion.
What it shows more than if they can be trusted is that you cannot.
It shows a lack of honesty and integrity on your part.
It shows your motivations are always questionable since more often than not, one of your Fine Speeches turns into abuse against others.