Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12
Results 11 to 12 of 12
Like Tree1Likes

Thread: The dumbest star trek moment I ever watched.

  1. #11
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Oct 2011
    Posts
    1,951

    Default Re: The dumbest star trek moment I ever watched.

    The romulan Nero in the reboot has to drill into planets to get the red matter to make a black hole to suck it in. But Spock can just throw a bottle of it out a window and it'll absorb all the energy of a supernova. Just crashing the spinner into Nero's ship releases it and it makes a black hole. So why drill into a planet first? A simple Perils of Pauline tied to the railroad tracks plot slowdown device.
    Lies have the stench of death and defeat.

  2. #12
    Moderator Neverfly's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Location
    Utopia Planetia, Mars
    Posts
    1,784

    Default Re: The dumbest star trek moment I ever watched.

    Quote Originally Posted by astrotech View Post
    The romulan Nero in the reboot has to drill into planets to get the red matter to make a black hole to suck it in. But Spock can just throw a bottle of it out a window and it'll absorb all the energy of a supernova. Just crashing the spinner into Nero's ship releases it and it makes a black hole. So why drill into a planet first? A simple Perils of Pauline tied to the railroad tracks plot slowdown device.
    If we assume that Spocks goal by tossing some "Red Matter Unobtainium" into the soon to go SuperNova star, is to save the planet Romulus, we reach two possibilities:
    1.) Not create a black hole, as that would doom Romulus too. Instead, change the gravitational pull of the star (increase it) just enough for it to balance out the forces trying to blow it apart or keep it from collapsing.
    This, of course makes no sense by any understanding of Physics.
    2.) Spock knew that the star would collapse into a black hole and doom Romulus. But that threat would be less immediate than the SuperNova, buying Romulus and friends time to evacuate Romulus and resettle the population in a system less inhospitable.
    If Nero had every intent of turning planet Vulva into a black hole, he would want to drill to the center to ensure the proper formation of collapse, which would be the ONLY part of the plot which would make any sense in any understanding of physics that we have. Because this exotic Red Matter that is a goopy fluid they can contain in a glass jar having the ability to form a dinky little speck of rock into a rare and powerful black hole most certainly defies even the most ignorant understanding of physics.
    The crashing of the ship containing a large amount of Red Matter into Neros ship creating a black hole is pretty bad. Adding to it the Enterprise detonating a series of Warp Cores (Seriously, it launched a buttload of them at the thing) and riding the wave away from the gravity well of a Black hole that it could not escape while warping space without it being reduced to subatomic particles is far worse.
    The reboot movie was Character Development and Special Effects only. It was not a reboot, IMHO, as it allows little room for a bunch of follow up films. But as far as the science in it, it cannot be taken with a grain of salt, even.
    Rather, you need a few hundred kilos of Atropine.
    --Inter Arma Enim Silent Leges--
    “Science needs the light of free expression to flourish. It depends on the fearless questioning of authority, and the open exchange of ideas.” ― Neil deGrasse Tyson

    "When photons interact with electrons, they are interacting with the charge around a "bare" mass, and thus the interaction is electromagnetic, hence light. This light slows the photon down." - BuleriaChk

Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •